What is a Birther? And a Truther?

Birtherism and Truthism are two of the most tenacious contemporary conspiracy theories.

What is the 'birther' theory?

The 'birther' movement insists that Barack Obama was not born in Hawaii as he has stated - but in Kenya. This is popularly (though incorrectly, see here) believed to make him ineligible to be US president.
Copy of certificate in 2011 failed to convince some birthers

Some allege that the story can originally be sourced to Hillary Clinton confidant Sydney Blumenthal during the 2008 primary campaign but it remained largely on the fringes of the right until it was famously taken up by one Donald J Trump in 2011. 

Trump repeatedly alluded to 'doubts' about the validity of the published birth certificate until finally conceding that “President Barack Obama was born in the United States, period' this month

What is Truther theory? 

Truthers allege that the official version of 9/11 is a cover story for a conspiracy. The exact nature of this conspiracy varies but usually a involves some or all of the usual conspiracy-theory suspects: Big Business, Big Oil, Dick Cheney, the FBI, the CIA, Israel, the Bilderberg Group.

Variations on truther theory are still publically expressed. British celebrity Russell Brand  declared on BBC Newsnight that he has 'an open mind' about the 9/11 attack on the Twin Towers. He was alluding to the claims of the so-called 'truther' movement which emerged in the early 2000s.

But we know what happened on 9/11, don’t we?  
'Truthers' question dismiss all the known evidence and suggest wildly improbable alternative theories. (See here for a comprehensive and systematic rebuttal of the main Truther claims.) 

Were there conspiracy theories before 9/11?
Extreme scepticism about 'official' history has a long history in the USA. It gained momentum after the Kennedy assassination with the rise  - of  'second shooter' theories etc.

The Watergate affair then appeared to give legitimacy to a cynical interpretation of the behaviour of the US Government and its agencies.

Ironically, it has been the brutal reality of terrorist atrocities that has undermined the Truther movement. Whatever Americans feel about their politicians, few doubt that there is a live and present danger to their security.  


  1. A brilliant summary of approach to take with 'truthers' from the historian Andrew Roberts: The only thing that sane people can do is to repeat, slowly and comprehensively and often, that no, Jesus wasn’t the first Freemason, that The Protocols of the Elders of Zion was a czarist forgery, that Jews weren’t told to absent themselves from work in the Twin Towers on 9/11, that William Shakespeare wrote the works of the playwright called William Shakespeare, that there wasn’t a plot to kill New Orleans’s black population during Hurricane Katrina, that the Queen of England is not an international drug dealer, that AIDS wasn’t invented by the CIA to cull global population, that aircraft vapor trails don’t contain chemicals designed to alter human behavior, that the government is not inserting microchips into our bloodstream, that Mohamed Atta does not have a body double, and so on and so interminably on. But then perhaps I’ve written all this just because I’m secretly in the pay of the Vatican, MI5, and the Mossad.

    See full article here: http://nrd.nationalreview.com/article/?q=MGJjYjAwNGZjNzVlNThmNjJjZjAwNTA2YTlmNTFkY2U=

  2. So, all "conspiracies" must be labeled absurd as well as the people who believe in the possibility of their existence? Is that not a generalization?

    1. A fair point but I think it is fair to say that the wilder conspiracy theories described above are undermined by their improbability and lack of evidence. I would also make a distinction between those whose views are - in my mind - simply mistaken and those with more malevolent intent. To say that you are not convinced of the official explanation for the collapse of the towers is one thing - to blame it on the Israelis suggests a dangerously distorted worldview.

  3. I think evolution is a joke. For good reason.
    May as well assigne me a group name, too.


Post a comment